In a surprising move, Detroit Lions head coach Dan Campbell decided to field his starting lineup in the preseason game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. This decision sparked controversy among fans and analysts alike, with many questioning the wisdom of putting potential starters at risk in a meaningless game.
Legendary quarterback Troy Aikman expressed his surprise over Campbell's decision during the broadcast of the game. "I'm surprised that they're playing their starters," Aikman said. "I think it's a risky move, especially considering how important this season is for them."
Aikman's concerns are valid. Preseason games are notorious for injuries, and teams typically use them to evaluate younger players and depth. By playing starters, Campbell risked losing key players before the regular season even began.
Campbell defended his decision by arguing that it was important to get his starters some live game experience before the regular season. "We need to get these guys on the field and let them play," Campbell said. "We're not going to learn anything if they're sitting on the sidelines."
Campbell also noted that the Steelers were fielding their starters as well, so the Lions would not be at a competitive disadvantage.
Data from previous seasons supports Aikman's concerns about injuries in preseason games. According to a study by the NFL, there were an average of 4.2 injuries per team in preseason games between 2015 and 2019.
However, Campbell's argument that game experience is important is also supported by data. A study by the University of California, Los Angeles found that rookie quarterbacks who played more snaps in the preseason performed better in their first regular season game.
Former NFL coach Herm Edwards agreed with Aikman's assessment that playing starters in the preseason is risky. "I wouldn't do it," Edwards said. "I've seen too many players get hurt in preseason games."
However, former NFL general manager Mike Tannenbaum disagreed. "I think it's a good move," Tannenbaum said. "I would rather get my starters some live reps than have them sitting on the sidelines."
The decision of whether or not to play starters in the preseason is ultimately a judgment call by the coaching staff. There are valid arguments to be made on both sides of the issue.
In the case of the Lions, the decision to field starters was made more complicated by the fact that the team is rebuilding and has a new coaching staff. However, Campbell is confident that his decision will benefit the team in the long run.
The Lions' decision to field starters in the preseason has raised questions about the larger issue of player safety in the NFL. While there is no doubt that preseason games can be dangerous, it is equally clear that some game experience is necessary for players to be fully prepared for the regular season.
The NFL must continue to balance the need for player safety with the desire to provide teams with the best possible chance to succeed. This is a difficult challenge, but it is one that the league must address in order to ensure the long-term health of the sport.